The following mail was sent to Barak Ravid of Haaretz following an article he wrote on Wednesday 19th November containing the quote below:
Dear Mr Ravid:
We were surprised to see an Israeli government spokesman, the Foreign Ministry’s Emmanuel Nashon, accuse foreign media writing about recent events in Jerusalem of aiding terrorists.
“From our perspective, tendentious and false reports are designed to distort reality, to blacken the State of Israel and practically – though not always intentionally – they provide support to terror,” Mr Nahshon wrote in remarks commented in your article published in Wednesday’s Ha’aretz.
Whatever the merits or faults of any individual news reports Mr Nashon may have in mind, we reject this blanket condemnation of foreign media. We think his emotive words are inappropriate for an Israeli government official responsible for working with foreign journalists, not least at a time of increased tensions and accusations of political incitement in the region where we work.
Sincere regards, The Forign Pess Association. November 19th, 2014
The Foreign Press calls on the Israeli border police to put an immediate end to a wave of attacks on journalists. In just over a week, border police officers have carried out at least four attacks on journalists working for international media organizations, injuring reporters and damaging expensive equipment. These attacks all appear to have been unprovoked:
_ On Oct. 26, an AP photographer in the West Bank village of Silwad was shot with rubber-coated pellets fired at close range by a border policeman who jumped out of a jeep and fired without warning. The pellets were released simultaneously out of a single canister, injuring a second photographer as well. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZGfniIaGk2U
_ On Oct. 31, a CCTV correspondent and cameraman covering Friday prayers in east Jerusalem had a stun grenade thrown directly at their feet from a distance of three meters. After the attack, a commander ordered the officer not to throw stun grenades at journalists.
_ On Nov. 2, a Reuters journalist covering a visit to the Temple Mount by an Israeli lawmaker was shoved by a border policeman without explanation. The border policeman tried to grab the reporter’s passport and ripped the front pocket of his shirt. Several hours later, another border policeman swore at a Reuters photographer in the Old City, pushed him and grabbed his camera. The border policeman than snapped the lens off the camera in a fit of rage, destroying an 8,000-shekel piece of equipment.
The FPA strongly protests such unwarranted attacks on its members. Unfortunately, such incidents have become all too common in recent years, despite repeated appeals and meetings with the relevant authorities. We once again call on the Israeli border police to respect the rights of journalists to do their jobs and uphold Israel’s stated commitment to freedom of the press.
November 3rd 2014
The Foreign Press Association deplores the Israeli authorities’ closing of the Erez border crossing into the Gaza Strip from Friday, November 1, until further notice, with no reason given.
Even before this closure, the FPA also received numerous complaints about difficulties experienced by journalists seeking to enter or leave Gaza.
Foreign journalists in Israel and the Palestinian territories work according to the law, and object vociferously to these restrictions on our ability to move freely and do our jobs.
We call on the Israeli authorities to lift these restrictions without delay. We also remind them of an Israeli Supreme Court decision from 2009 endorsing the principle of unfettered access to the Gaza Strip for foreign media.
November 3rd, 2014
Following two incidents in which journalists were directly attacked by border police, the FPA wishes to reiterate that deliberate attacks on identifiable journalists on assignment are not acceptable.
In one incident, a CCTV correspondent and cameraman covering Friday prayers in Jerusalem’s Old City had a stun grenade thrown directly at them from a distance of three meters away. This happened just seconds after a border policeman shouted at them to leave.
In a direct indication that it was clear to the forces that they were not to act this way, the commander reprimanded him, suggesting that although such orders exist, they are not always enforced on the ground.
Two days later, an AP photographer and another foreign journalist were hit by rubber bullets fired at close range by a border policeman as they took pictures of protesters in the West Bank town of Silwad. They were not near the protesters at the time and the area had not been designated as off limits.
The FPA strongly protests the deliberate act of firing of tear gas, stun grenades and rubber bullets at journalists who are clearly identifiable and demands that clear orders be given to this effect to the forces operating the ground, with any violation swiftly disciplined.
October 28th 2014
Photojournalists from AP, AFP and Reuters were covering the protest march after Friday prayers in Hebron today when Israeli security forces began firing rubber bullets at the protesters. As in previous incidents, the forces then hurled stun grenades towards the press crews to try to disburse them. An AP TV journalist was detained, an AFP photographer was roughly deterred from covering the event and a rubber bullet hit the wind-shied of the Reuters TV vehicle, clearly marked with "PRESS TV". The photographers and camera crews were standing apart from the protesters.
The FPA has countless times condemned and protested against the IDF and border police for using strong arm tactics against known and recognised press photographers in these situations. The authorities have just as many times promised to investigate these incidents and somehow the results of these investigations seem to disappear into the dustbin of history.
Press freedom is the signal of a civilised nation. The assault and humiliation of reporters trying to do their work is unacceptable and falls far, far below the standards that the IDF in all its branches says it adheres to.
August 15th, 2014
The FPA protests in the strongest terms the blatant, incessant, forceful and unorthodox methods employed by the Hamas authorities and their representatives against visiting international journalists in Gaza over the past month.
The international media are not advocacy organisations and cannot be prevented from reporting by means of threats or pressure, thereby denying their readers and viewers an objective picture from the ground.
In several cases, foreign reporters working in Gaza have been harassed, threatened or questioned over stories or information they have reported through their news media or by means of social media.
We are also aware that Hamas is trying to put in place a "vetting" procedure that would, in effect, allow for the blacklisting of specific journalists. Such a procedure is vehemently opposed by the FPA.
August 11, 2014
The FPA strongly condemns deliberate official and unofficial incitement against journalists working to cover the current warfare under very difficult circumstances as well as forcible attempts to prevent journalists and TV crews from carrying out their news assignments. While we do not condone the use of invective by any side, outright attacks on journalists are absolutely unacceptable.
On Tuesday, IDF forces aimed live fire at the Al Jazeera offices in Gaza City. The offices are on the 11th floor of a known commercial centre. The IDF apologised claiming it was in error and said they would investigate the incident.
Also Tuesday, FPA member Firas Khatib of BBC Arabic was physically attacked and abused in the midst of a live feed on the Israeli side of the border. July 23, 2014
In Hebron today a number of foreign media crews were covering the solidarity protest for Palestinian prisoners on hunger strike, CNN were directly targeted by the PA police and preventive security forces. In the midst of clearing and breaking up the protest, the undercover police attacked the CNN crew including senior correspondent, Ben Wedeman, Cameraman Joe Sheffer and producer Kareem Khadder without any warning. One of the plain clothes undercover police was overheard giving orders to take the camera from the cameraman. The crew kept trying to save the EX1 Sony camera but another undercover policeman kept grabbing it from them until it lay in pieces. As well as being bruised and scratched, the crew were accused of "incitement".
The FPA condemns this behaviour towards known journalists in the strongest terms and we call on the heads of the various security forces to clearly instruct their underlings to stay clear of journalists on assignment in the field. Deliberate violence and intimidation against professional journalists carrying out their work anywhere is totally unacceptable. 20th June 2014
The FPA strongly condemns the thuggish behaviour and deliberate intimidation demonstrated by Israeli border police against journalists and cameramen covering the events at Damascus Gate on Jerusalem Day 28.5.2014 .
Despite the fact that both the photographers and cameramen stood in an area designated for the press, mounted border police officers aggressively forced them to move far from the scene. Others were violently pushed, kicked and blocked from working. One photographer was punched in the stomach while he had his hands in the air, another was hit in the stomach with an M16 and a third narrowly avoided a punch to the face.
The border police also threw stun grenades directly at photographers, in a display of aggression which has shocked veteran photographers and cameramen who have worked in the region for a long time.
Although the foreign police spokesman came quickly to the scene, his intervention made no practical difference whatsoever, with the forces continuing to lash out at accredited journalists trying to work – Israelis, Palestinians and foreigners alike. Police also failed to prevent demonstrators from attacking journalists – in one case marchers snatched a large tripod from a photographer and beat him with it.
Repeated requests expressed by the FPA in meetings with the various authorities, have brought no concrete results. The FPA can only conclude that this level of aggression against journalists doing their job, is less a matter of orders given by commanders on the ground at any given time, but rather a clear change in policy towards the media in general. In a country which brands itself the only democracy in the Middle East, this level of aggression against the press cannot be tolerated and we urge the authorities to open an immediate investigation to determine who was responsible and ensure it does not happen again. 29th May 2014.
The FPA condemns in the strongest terms the attack on journalists in Ramallah. The FPA insists that everyone respect the right of journalists on assignment to work unharmed in order to freely and unhindered pursue their profession. We ask the authorities in Ramallah to take responsibility to prevent such attacks in the future. May 5th, 2014
The FPA joins the AP to strongly protest a shooting incident yesterday ( Sunday) near the Aida refugee camp, in which it appears a border policeman fired on a marked AP car as it was obeying instructions to leave. The details are these:
_ On Sunday, AP television cameraman Eyad Moghrabi rushed to Aida camp to film clashes between Israeli forces and Palestinian protesters.
_ He encountered border police just outside Aida’s entrance, next to the separation barrier. A policeman told him to leave.
_ He immediately turned around, and as he drove away, he heard a loud thump. Terrified, he fled the area and later discovered a bullet hole in the back of his car.
_ This morning, an investigation found that the bullet penetrated only the outer layer of the car. Based on the size of the hole, we believe the damage was caused by a round, rubber-coated bullet used by the border police to disperse crowds.
The Associated Press strongly condemns the unnecessary and apparently intentional use of this weapon against an unarmed journalist. Moghrabi was nowhere near any of the protesters at the time and had clearly obeyed the security forces' orders. He was wearing a blue vest marked "press" and was driving in a car with "Foreign Press" stickers in the windows.
The Associated Press demands an explanation why Israeli forces deemed him a threat and would attack him unprovoked.
Unfortunately, this is only the latest in a string of heavy-handed assaults by border police on journalists. These raise troubling questions about the professionalism of Israeli security forces and the government's commitment to freedom of the press. Security personnel should have the clearest possible instructions not only to not attack media members but to provide them protection and treat them with respect. March 24th, 2014
The FPA condemns in the strongest of terms a series of text messages sent to the mobile phones of well over 60 foreign correspondents and journalists working for foreign news outlets from what appears to be a carefully selected data base set up by the military wing of Hamas, the al-Qassam Brigades. These messages, which included direct threats to our members including one from ``kill you'' that said ``Hamas ... In the next war all of Palestine will be returned'' and one from a 057 number that said ``al-Qassam has chosen you to be The next SHalite .. Be Ready.''
This is unacceptable. Journalists are not part of the Middle East conflict. They are observers who should be treated as such.
The FPA calls on the Hamas government to take steps to guarantee this never happens again. March 23rd, 2014.
The FPA deplores yet again violence by Israeli security forces directed at journalists.
During clashes tonight at the Damascus Gate, a border policeman fired a rubber bullet from close quarters at a Reuters cameraman in an apparent effort to prevent him filming the arrest of a protester. Another border policeman then clubbed his video camera, smashing the light. An AP photographer was punched in the face and suffered a bloody nose.
The FPA has repeatedly issued statements condemning the behavior of certain members of the Israeli security forces. The authorities routinely play down our concerns or fail to carry out timely investigations of our complaints. Such violence will surely one day lead to serious injury, or even worse. So we therefore repeat our request for the security forces to allow FPA members to carry out their jobs in a professional manner, as befits any democracy. We ask the police and army not to deliberately target journalists and we ask them to investigate fully repeated instances of clear wrong-doing by the security forces.
March 11th 2014
The Foreign Press Association condemns the behavior of an Israeli policeman who acted in a violent, provocative and unprofessional fashion during disturbances on Feb. 28 in East Jerusalem.
The man In question, who was wearing a balaclava that clearly identified him as a policeman, rushed wildly towards a group of journalists recording the day’s clashes and pointed his pistol straight at their faces. A short while later, the same policeman hurled a stun grenade at a some photographers who were standing just a short distance away and again brandished his gun at nearby reporters.
We call on the Israeli police to do their utmost to guarantee the safety of journalists and provide more thorough training for their officers to prevent such incidents, which one day will surely end in tragedy.
The FPA replies to the IDF response from last night:
The Foreign Press Association feels the IDF statement regarding the Nov. 29 incident at the Qalandiya crossing to be misleading and unsatisfactory.
During the incident, troops fired rubber bullets and threw stun grenades directly at a group of working journalists. The IDF’s statement does not explain why troops fired rubber bullets at eye-level, rather than at the lower body, which in this incident could have resulted in a fatality. It also gives no answer or explanation as to why someone threw a stun grenade at the back of a group of photographers who had made clear to them that they were walking away from the scene.
Once again, we urge the IDF to investigate the very real concerns that we raised. The photojournalists were clearly identified and there can be no excuses made for the way in which they were treated. By turning a blind eye to clear breaches of protocol, and repeatedly failing to properly investigate similar incidents in the past, we fear the IDF is creating a culture of impunity within its ranks that only serves to perpetuate an already dangerous situation.
The FPA also urges the IDF to communicate clearly to soldiers working in the field that they must not target the press. December 2nd. 2013
IDF response:On the 29th of November ,2013, an illegal and violent protest took place at the Qalandia Crossing, during which fire bombs were thrown and rocks hurled towards security forces, who responded accordingly with riot dispersal means. Throughout the provocation, photojournalists were sighted adjacent and in the midst of the rioters, putting themselves at risk. In the initial IDF review of the incident the IDF concluded that the rubber bullet which hit the photojournalist's camera, who was in the vicinity of violent protesters, was not intentionally fired towards him, but part of the riot dispersal means which were aimed at disbanding the protest. The European Media Desk (IDF)
On Friday afternoon, Israeli forces threw stun grenades at FPA photojournalists (among them representatives of AFP and other freelancers) as they were leaving Qalandia. The FPA members had put their hands in the air, indicating to the forces that they were leaving at which point the grenades were thrown from close quarters directly at their backs.
Earlier, at the same demonstration, an Italian freelance photographer was almost shot in the face by troops firing at eye level. Fortunately the photographer was taking pictures at the time and the rubber bullet shattered the camera instead of his head. All the photographers in question wore clearly-marked jackets and helmets. There is no question that the forces were directly targeting the journalists.
In February, the FPA issued a statement noting that the army and military police have a dismal track record for investigating such incidents. Over the past two years, the FPA has demanded investigations into some 10 incidents in which journalists appear to have been abused by Israeli security forces. As far as we know, just two investigations have been launched, WITH NO RESULTS. The others have been ignored.
The Turkel Commission has stated that the military’s investigative processes suffer from “structural problems.” A proper investigation into violence against the media and holding soldiers accountable for their actions would be a very practical first step towards rectifying these problems.
The Board of the Foreign Press Association, December 1st, 2013
Several months later and the offices in Gaza are still closed - from July 27th 2013.
The Foreign Press Association deplores the Hamas government's decision to close down media operations in the Gaza Strip including the offices of Al Arabiyeh. Hamas is not only acting in contradiction to the freedom of press and freedom of speech, it is hurting itself by not allowing press coverage of the territory it governs. The Hamas government's crackdown on the media organizations is cause for grave concern.
The FPA calls on the Hamas to allow Al Arabiyeh and other media organizations immediate access to their offices, equipment and to resume their news assignments without impediment.
The Foreign Press Association 27th July 2013
The Foreign Press Association is shocked and appalled that the prime minister's security detail strip-searched an al-Hurra cameraman who was providing pool coverage of the July 4 party at the U.S. ambassador's residence in Herzliya. We believe that he was targeted because he is Arab.
Samer Jallad, who has covered the prime minister many times before, says he had registered with the prime minister’s office ahead of time and arrived several hours before the celebration to ensure a smooth entry. Although he holds a GPO press card, he nonetheless was subjected to more than 15 minutes of hostile questioning, ordered to take off his shoes and sit in the sun for more than half an hour, and then taken to a closed room where he was forced to remove his pants for a body inspection. In all, it took nearly 90 minutes before he was permitted to enter the event. His Israeli colleagues entered without incident.
This is the latest in a series of cases of unnecessary harassment of accredited Arab journalists in Israel. We find it especially shameful that a staffer of a U.S.-funded network would be the victim of racial profiling at an official U.S. event celebrating American Independence Day. Such treatment goes against the core values of freedom and equality that the U.S. seeks to uphold.
We urge the U.S. government to condemn this in the strongest terms.
4th July 2013
The Foreign Press Association strongly protests the behaviour of the border policemen who were present during a demonstration against the barrier in the Ramallah outskirts on Wednesday. Security men used unnecessary and unjustified force against the journalists from AP, Xinhua and Reuters. In one case they fired a tear gas canister that was aimed between the legs of a female journalist covering the protest. She suffered burns to her leg.
We would like to point out that the journalists were located some 300 meters away from the protesters when they were harassed by the forces.
After a period of relative calm, and few incidents, the FPA calls on the border police to deal with this promptly to avoid escalation.
The Board of the Foreign Press Association, July 4th 2013.
On Saturday March 30th , Israeli forces threw stun grenades at photographers and cameramen covering unrest at the Qalandia checkpoint outside Jerusalem. The journalists were working for a number of major international news organizations, including The Associated Press, Reuters, AFP and Xinhua, and were hundreds of meters away from clashes with Palestinian protesters had taken place. This was the latest in a string of similar attacks on journalists in recent weeks.
Given the distance of these attacks from the broader clashes, this incident raises troubling questions over whether Israeli forces are intentionally targeting journalists -- a practice that is usually associated with some of the neighboring countries in the region. We condemn this behavior in the strongest terms and renew our calls to the Israeli border police and other forces to do their utmost to guarantee the safety of journalists. We also hope that the border police will follow up on previous pledges to work with the international media to avoid similar violence in the future. Video:
On Saturday, an AP photographer covering disturbances in the West Bank village of Yatta was detained by Israeli forces and forced to sit, with his hands bound behind his back, for five hours before he was released without charge. The photographer says that at no time did soldiers tell him or provide documentation saying the area had been declared a closed military zone. In addition, he says that throughout the incident he followed soldiers’ orders as to where to stand. During his detention, he was not given food or water, and soldiers refused a request to get up to relieve himself.
This is the latest in a string of incidents involving heavy-handed tactics against journalists who were merely trying to do their jobs. The FPA condemns this violence and once against calls on the army to thoroughly investigate this incident.
It also would like to remind the army and military police that the record on investigating these incidents has been dismal. The FPA has demanded investigations into some ten incidents in which journalists appear to have been abused by Israeli security forces in the course over 2012 and 2013. As far as we know, just two investigations have been launched, and the others remain open.
As the Turkel Commission noted last week, the military’s investigative processes suffer from “structural problems.” Properly investigating violence against the media and holding soldiers accountable for their actions would be a good way to begin rectifying these problems.
The Foreign Press Association February 10, 2013
Israeli border police forces verbally and physically assaulted an unarmed, female AP TV producer during last weekend's protests in the West Bank village of Burin, pushing her onto a pile of rocks and insulting her. When colleagues tried to help her off the ground, forces prevented them from reaching her and then blocked them from taking her to an ambulance. It is important to note that the incident occurred before the military declared the area a closed zone. While the producer did not suffer any broken bones, she is in great pain and has been unable to work since the incident.
Also in Burin, an officer threatened AFP photographer Jaafar Ashtiye as he documented the events, warning him he would be arrested at his home, in front of his children, during the night if he did not stop taking pictures. A military spokesman has agreed that the soldier's remarks were inappropriate and promised the incident would be investigated, but AFP has heard nothing further on this.
The FPA condemns the security force's behavior in both incidents the strongest terms and urges prompt investigations.
It should be noted that both the military and the military police have poor records when it comes to investigating such incidents.
In the past year alone, Israeli authorities have promised to investigate at least five FPA complaints of inappropriate violence against journalists, some of which were captured on film. As far as we know, all of these investigations remain open, and authorities have never provided any update on the status of any of them.
This lack of transparency questions about the military authority’s stated commitment to protecting freedom of the press. With this in mind, we appeal to the Military Advocate General and the Justice Ministry’s internal police investigation unit to take over the investigations, promptly complete them and take all appropriate disciplinary action.
In order to assist the government with this task, we are attaching three photos of the incident involving the AP producer, as well as a fourth picture of the same border policeman spraying pepper spray on protesters. We have also attached two videos: The first shows parts of the incident in which the producer was beaten. The second shows whom we believe to be the same border policeman hitting a protester with his rifle.
We hope that the relevant authorities will consider our request and take incidents like these more seriously than the security forces. http://www.raya.ps/ar/raya-tube/817407-.html http://www.raya.ps/ar/raya-tube/817406-.html The Foreign Press Association February 6th, 2013
In what seems to be becoming a regular pattern, Israeli security forces have again assaulted FPA journalists covering unrest in the West Bank.
On Saturday, border police tossed stun grenades toward photographers from the AP, Reuters, SIPA and other agencies who were covering a demonstration at the Hizme checkpoint near Jerusalem. The journalists say the grenades were tossed multiple times, and in at least one instance, landed on the feet of a photographer.
There is strong evidence the photographers were deliberately targeted. They were not participating in the protest, and had moved to the side of the road, away from demonstrators, at the instruction of the border police before they were attacked. When the journalists attempted to complain, the border police commander at the scene refused to speak to them.
We condemn this unprofessional conduct in the strongest terms, and call for a thorough investigation. After receiving promises days ago from both the border police and the IDF for better working relations, we have yet to see a real investigation with real results. All the incidents below remain open for 2012 and 2013. The Foreign Press Association March 11th 2013
The Foreign Press Association begins 2013 as it ended 2012, dealing with the brutality of Israeli security services who consistently assault legitimate journalists who are members of our organisation as they try to cover media worthy events, this time in the E1 area.
The Foreign Press Association is growing increasingly frustrated as its journalists are consistently unable to cover media events. Complaints are ignored, promised investigations are not completed in a reasonable period of time, or they are never completed at all.
Yesterday, photographers posing no threat to soldiers or activists were assaulted by security officials, their equipment damaged and causing them bodily harm. Earlier this week, journalists were obstructed in doing their job by security officials flashing spotlights into the cameras. And in a final step that appears to be further aimed at discouraging media coverage, all the press cars at the E1 site yesterday were issued parking tickets, despite one of them being told where to park by the officials themselves.
This continued situation raises some serious questions regarding freedom of access and Israel's adherence to freedom of the press. The FPA calls on Israeli authorities to take the appropriate steps against those who continue to obstruct the press, to issue appropriate rules and regulations and properly brief security men and women before they are sent out to deal with events that will be covered by media. The Board of the Foreign Press Association, 16th January 2013